Legal Support for Participative Decision-Making as Part of ‘Service’ Model of Urban Governance in Russia

Main Article Content

Svetlana Martynova
Vladimir Tabolin
Polina Sazonova


The research deals with urban governance in Russia from the perspective of the participative approach to decision-making. The authors used quantitative (semi-structured 'face-to-face' interview) and qualitative (in-depth semi-structured interview) sociological surveys in five cities of Russia over the period from 2001 to 2017 regarding the public expectations towards the service activity of the urban governance authorities. The respondents were the citizens over 18-years-old who live in Tomsk, Seversk, and Strezhevoy in Tomsk Region. The authors have analysed the official documents and the information of the federal and municipal level over the period from 1997 to 2018. It was stated that the citizens' preferences had changed from paternalistic to 'service' ones, but in most cases, the legal framework was based on the directive principle of decision-making and did not comply with public demands. The technology of participative decision-making in the sphere of public services in Russia, in particular, in the cities, gradually develop. The content of such decisions increasingly reflects public expectations. Taking into account the results of the sociological surveys and the analysis of the regulatory support for the public service delivery, the authors have developed the recommendations on the improvement of the legal regulation based on the participative principle.

Article Details

How to Cite
Martynova, S., Tabolin, V., & Sazonova, P. (2019). Legal Support for Participative Decision-Making as Part of ‘Service’ Model of Urban Governance in Russia. Space and Culture, India, 7(2), 112-124.
Themed Issue


Abikenov, A., Idrysheva, S. K., Zharbolova, A. Z., Apakhayev, N., Buribayev, Y. A., Khamzina, Z. A. (2019). The problems of effectiveness and implementation of the international legal norms of the states of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU). Bulletin of the Georgian National Academy of Sciences, 13(1), 175-181.
Administration of Seversk. (2018). Register of Municipal Services. Retrieved from
Akhmetshin, E. M., Barmuta, K. A., Yakovenko, Z. M., Zadorozhnaya, L. I., Mironov, D. S., & Klochko, E. N. (2017). Advantages of cluster approach in managing the economy of the Russian Federation. International Journal of Applied Business and Economic Research, 15(23), 355-364.
Arduini, D., & Zanfei, А. (2014). An Overview of Scholarly Research on Public E-Services? A Meta-Analysis of the Literature. Telecommunications Policy, 38(5), 476-495.
Asmu'i, A., & Fitriati, R. (2014). Applying Interactive Planning on Leadership in the Organization: The Case of Transforming Public Transport Services in Banjarmasin. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 115, 283-295.
Atanelishvili, T., & Silagadze, A. (2018). Formation of economic views in the ancient era. Bulletin of the Georgian National Academy of Sciences, 2(1), 191-196.
Avzalova, E. I. (2015). Internet Participation as a New Form of Political Participation of Citizens. Scientific Notes of Kazan University. Series Humanities, 157(1), 187-193.
Bidaishiyeva, A., Nadirova, K.K., Kuldinova, S., Apakhayev, N., Khamzina, Z.A., Buribayev, Y.A. (2018). Improving quality of legal regulation for social rights of family and child within new social course in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues, 21(1), 1544-0044-21-1-165.
Busetti, S., & Dente, B. (2016). Designing multi-actor implementation: A mechanism-based approach. Public Policy and Administration, 33(1), 46-65.
Coste, A., & Tudor, A.T. (2013). Service Performance – between Measurement and Information in the Public Sector. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences, 92, 215-219.
Desrieux, C., Chong, E., & Saussier, S. (2013). Putting all One's Eggs in One Basket: Relational Contracts and the Management of Local Public Services. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 89, 167-186.
Djellal, F., Gallouj, F., & Miles, I. (2013). Two Decades of Research on Innovation in Services: Which Place for Public Services? Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 27, 98-117.
Gavrilova, I.N. (2012). Civic Participation in Russia and the Netherlands: Problems and Prospects. Problem Analysis and Public-Management Design, 5(25), 6-13.
Government of the Russian Federation. (1997). Decree of February 10, 1997 No 155 "On approval of the Rules for the provision of services for the removal of liquid domestic waste". Retrieved on 03 April 2019 from,
Government of the Russian Federation. (2005). Order of October 25, 2005 No 1789-r "The Concept of Administrative Reform in the Russian Federation in 2006-2010". Retrieved on 03 April 2019 from,
Government of the Russian Federation. (2009). Decree of June 15th, 2009 N 478 "On a unified system of information and reference support for citizens and organizations on issues of interaction with executive authorities and local self-government bodies using the information and telecommunications network Internet". Retrieved on 03 April 2019 from,
Government of the Russian Federation. (2012). Resolution of December 17, 2012 No. 1317 "On Measures for the Implementation of Presidential Decree No. 607 of April 28, 2008, "On Evaluating the Efficiency of Local Self-Government Bodies in the Urban Districts and Municipal Areas "and Subparagraph" i "of Point 2 of the Decree of the President of the Russian Federation May 7, 2012 â„– 601 "On the main directions of improving the system of public administration". Retrieved on 01 April 2019 from,
Government of the Russian Federation. (2013a). Decree of September 5, 2013 N 661 "On approval of the Rules for the development, approval of federal state educational standards and amendments thereto". Retrieved on 03 April 2019 from,
Government of the Russian Federation. (2013b). Order of May 15, 2013 N 792-r "Development of Education" for 2013- 020 years". Retrieved on 02 April 2019 from, https://xn--80abucjiibhv9a.xn--p1ai/%D0%B4%D0%BE%D0%BA%D1%83%D0%BC%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%82%D1%8B/3409
Government of the Russian Federation. (2014a). Order of January 30, 2014 N 93-r "The concept of openness of federal executive bodies". Retrieved on 05 April 2019 from,
Government of the Russian Federation. (2014b). Order of September 04, 2014 N 1726-r "The concept of development of additional education for children". Retrieved on 07 April 2019 from,
Government of the Russian Federation. (2015). Decree of May 23, 2015 N 497 "On the Federal Target Program for the Development of Education for 2016-2020 years". Retrieved on 05 April 2019 from,
Kail, Ya.Ya., & Yepinina, V.S. (2013). Foreign experience of participatory orientation of public administration. National Interests: Priorities and Security, 2, 42.Barabashev, A. G., & Utkina, V. V. (2014). On the difference between analytics of public administration and public administration as a scientific direction. Public administration, 47, 19–38.
Karlina, A.A. (2013). City Development Management: Municipal Sustainability, Process Approach. Samara: SNC RAN.
Khaidarov, R. R. (2008). Municipal Services: Comparative Analysis. Vlast, 8, 48-52.
Kolesnikov, Yu. A., Pavlyuk, A. V., Radachinsky, Yu. N., & Rodionova, N. D. (2018). Problems of Implementation of Public-private partnership in Russia. European Research Studies Journal, 21, 187-197.
Kruks-Wisner, G. (2011). Seeking the Local State: Gender, Caste, and the Pursuit of Public Services in Post-Tsunami India. World Development, 39(7), 1143-1154.
Lall, S. V., & Lundberg, M. (2007). What are Public Services Worth, and to Whom? Non-Parametric Estimation of Capitalization in Pune. Journal of Housing Economics, 17(1), 34-64.
Lerner, J., & Secondo, D. (2012). By the People, for the People: Participatory Budgeting from the Bottom up in North America. Journal of Public Deliberation, 8(2), Article 2. Retrieved on 05 April 2019 from,
Liu, H. K. (2017). Exploring Online Engagement in Public Policy Consultation: The Crowd or the Few? Australian Journal of Public Administration, 76(1), 33-47.
Local government of Strezhevoy. (2018). Standards of Information Disclosure in the Sphere of Disposal (Burial) of Solid Household Waste of LLC "TRANSSIB". Retrieved on 05 April 2019 from,
Maslov, D. V. (2009). Model CAF to Improve the Quality of Public Management. Public Service, 6, 67-69.
Mekhova, A. A. (2011). Foresight as a Modern Technology of Social Participation. Social Policy and Sociology, 8, 120-127.
Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation. (2018). Assistance in the Development of Civil Society Institutions. Retrieved on 07 April 2019 from,
Municipal Formation "City of Tomsk" (2017a). Results of the Federal Priority Project "Formation of a Comfortable Urban Environment" on the Territory of the Municipal Entity "City of Tomsk". Retrieved on 03 April 2019 from,
Municipal Formation "City of Tomsk". (2017b). Regulations on the Municipal Public Council for the Development of General Education and Additional Education for Children in the City of Tomsk. Retrieved on 03 April 2019 from,
Municipal Formation "City of Tomsk". (2018). List of Municipal Services. Retrieved on 05 April 2019 from,
Nabatchi, T. (2012). Putting the “Public” Back in Public Values Research: Designing Participation to Identify and Respond to Values. Public Administration Review, 72(5), 699–708.
President of the Russian Federation. (2012). Decree of May 7, 2012 No 601 "On the Main Directions of Improving the System of Public Administration". Retrieved on 06 April 2019 from,
Purcărea, V. L., Gheorghe, I. R., Petrescu, C. M. (2013). The Assessment of Perceived Service Quality of Public Health Care Services in Romania Using the SERVQUAL Scale. Procedia Economics and Finance, 6, 573-585.
Pyon, C. U., Lee, M. J., & Park, S. C. (2009). Decision Support System for Service Quality Management Using Customer Knowledge in Public Service Organization. Expert Systems with Application, 36(4), 8227-8238.
Rodrigues, A.B., Groenwold, J.A., Dias, R.S., & Benassi, S.F. (2018). Municipal basic sanitation planning: A methodology of support for local public management and a case. Periodico Tche Quimica, 15(29), 319-332.
Rozanova, N. N. (2013). Improving the Reputation of the Authorities: The Prospects for Introducing a Public Assessment of the Performance of Public Civil Servants. Quality Age, 3, 22-25.
Sharafutdinov, R. I., Gerasimov, V. O., Akhmetshin, E. M., Yumashev, A. V., Pavlyuk, A. V., & Luzina, T. V. (2018). Inclusive growth index assessment in the regions of the Volga Federal District of the Russian Federation. In Proceedings of the 31st International Business Information Management Association Conference – Innovation Management and Education Excellence through Vision 2020, pp. 3890-3902.
Silagadze, A. (2017). History of Georgian economic thought: Relation between the center and the region. Bulletin of the Georgian National Academy of Sciences, 11(4), 138-144.
Silagadze, A. (2018). Some aspects of economic ideas in Shota Rustaveli’s “the knight in the panther skin”. Bulletin of the Georgian National Academy of Sciences, 12(1), 161-167.
Sobaci, M. Z., & Karkin, N. (2013). The Use of Twitter by Mayors in Turkey: Tweets for Better Public Services? Government Information Quarterly, 30(4), 417-425.
State Duma. (1998). Federal Law of June 24, 1998 No 89-FZ "On Production and Consumption Wastes". Retrieved on 04 April 2019 from,
State Duma. (2003). Federal Law of October 6, 2003 No 131-FZ "On the General Principles of the Organization of Local Government in the Russian Federation". Retrieved on 29 March 2019 from,
State Duma. (2004). The Housing Code of the Russian Federation of December 29, 2004 No 188-FZ. Retrieved on 30 March 2019 from,
State Duma. (2010). Federal Law of July 27, 2010 N 210-FZ "On the Organization of the Provision of State and Municipal Services". Retrieved on 25 March 2019 from,
State Duma. (2012). Federal Law of December 29, 2012 N 273-FZ "On Education in the Russian Federation". Retrieved on 28 March 2019 from,
State Duma. (2017). Federal Law of January 31, 2017 No 503-FZ "On Amending the Federal Law on Production and Consumption Wastes and Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation". Retrieved on 31 March 2019 from,
Sztompka, P. (2006). New Perspectives on Trust. American Journal of Sociology, 112(3), 905-919.
Tabolin, V. V. (2012). Sociality of City Law. State Power and Local Self-Government, 8, 3-6.
Touraine, A. (2007). Sociology after Sociology. European Journal of Social Theory, 10(2), 184-193.
Ushakov, D., Akhmetova, S. G., & Nevskaya, L. V. (2017). Economic growth and environmental performance: Correlation issues and future priorities. International Journal of Ecological Economics and Statistics, 38(4), 164-172.
Van, H. T., Huu, A. T., & Ushakov, D. (2017). Liberal reforms and economic growth: Current issues and interrelations. Journal of International Studies, 10(4), 109-118.
Vialova, L.M. (2004). The procedure for working with citizens. Ðœoscow: MTsFER.
Vinichenko, M. V., Makushkin, S. A., Melnichuk, A. V., Frolova, E. V., & Kurbakova, S. N. (2016). Student employment during college studies and after career start. International Review of Management and Marketing, 6(S5), 23-29.
Volkova, A.V. (2013). Mechanisms and methods for introducing the management of public values: Russian and foreign practices. Tambov: Gramota.